NSW Shelved Its Underquoting Reform Hours Before It Began. What Changes for Buyers?
The NSW government has paused new property advertising restrictions amid a falling market. Existing underquoting rules still matter.
Harbour Creative Team2 min read
Harbour Creative Team2 min readA new set of NSW real estate advertising rules was due to begin on Tuesday, 17 November. Instead, Premier Chris Minns intervened on Monday and the government announced a pause that could last up to a year. The late change leaves homebuyers trying to work out which price protections still apply.
The rule that caused the argument
The delayed reform would have prevented an agent from advertising a property below a written offer the seller had already rejected. The intention was understandable: buyers should not spend money and time on inspections or due diligence because a guide price is set below what a seller is prepared to accept.
But the housing market can move downward. A seller might reject an offer one month and later decide the same amount is acceptable. The government argued a rigid advertising floor could stop an agent reflecting that change.
Why the reversal matters
ABC News reported that other changes were also being put on hold, including new requirements to advertise a selling price or price range and a proposed penalty framework. The Real Estate Institute of NSW welcomed reconsideration, while opposition figures questioned why legislation had not accommodated a downturn in the first place.
Buyers are entitled to ask whether the reversal weakens transparency. Sellers are entitled to ask whether a price guide can adapt when demand falls. Both questions deserve answers grounded in the way the market actually works.
Underquoting was already against the law
The pause does not make misleading property advertising lawful. NSW's existing rules require a reasonable estimated selling price, supporting evidence and updates when material circumstances change.
Buyers should ask agents what comparable sales support the guide, whether the vendor has rejected offers and when the estimate was last revised. They should also record what they are told, particularly when paying for building reports, legal work and finance arrangements.
The unanswered question
The government needs to explain which precise elements are paused and publish clear, up-to-date guidance for agents and buyers. Some government guidance pages were still describing 17 November commencement when the last-minute announcement was made. That is a recipe for confusion.
A sensible reform should prevent deliberately low guides without preventing honest price reductions. The task is to design both protections into the same system, not treat the interests of buyers and sellers as mutually exclusive.
Sources and further reading
About this article
This article provides analysis and interpretation of available information. Sources and supporting material, where applicable, are linked within the article.
Found an error? Contact the editorial desk. See our editorial standards and corrections policy.
From the Harbour Creative Blogs archive
Keep exploring this story
Related reporting, people and places from our published coverage. These are editorial connections, not a popularity ranking.
Local coverage
Sydney
The business, communities, housing, transport, sport and public decisions affecting metropolitan Sydney.
Organisation
NSW Government
Government decisions affecting services, planning and households across New South Wales.
Person
Chris Minns
NSW Premier, covered through government decisions and proposals affecting the state.

