Part 3 · Analysis
Who Was Supposed to Protect First Guardian Investors?
The fund had managers, advisers, superannuation trustees and auditors. Regulators allege failures across several of those gates — and one major trustee has already admitted breaches.
Harbour Creative Team6 min read
Harbour Creative Team6 min read
The $600 Million Superannuation Scandal — Part 3
Reporting reviewed through 12 November 2026. Figures are Australian dollars. Allegations, established court findings and estimated losses are identified separately.
A fund can have a manager, financial advisers, platform trustees and external auditors — yet investors can still be left without access to their retirement savings.
That uncomfortable fact sits at the centre of the First Guardian affair.
The industry's safeguards are not supposed to be interchangeable. Each participant has a different job. Advisers should assess suitability and act in clients' interests. Superannuation trustees must exercise care in the investment choices made available to members. A fund's responsible entity must manage the scheme according to its obligations. Auditors are expected to obtain evidence before providing assurance about financial statements and compliance.
In First Guardian's case, ASIC is investigating or suing organisations and individuals across several of these roles. But not every case has reached the same legal stage. Some conduct has been admitted and declared in court. Other claims remain allegations.
The role of the superannuation platform
When an adviser-led member of a superannuation fund chooses a specialist investment, the platform may make that choice administratively possible. The trustee remains responsible for meeting legal obligations, including the way options are offered and monitored.
It does not necessarily mean the trustee has guaranteed that the investment cannot lose money. It does mean that trustees cannot simply assume another business has done all necessary due diligence.
ASIC's May 2026 platform trustee review and enforcement record show why the regulator now places particular emphasis on this distinction.
Netwealth: the established court outcome
The clearest completed example is Netwealth.
Between March 2021 and December 2022, about $128.5 million was invested across two First Guardian classes by 1,303 members of the Netwealth Superannuation Master Fund. When withdrawals were suspended in May 2024, approximately 1,080 members still held First Guardian investments.
Netwealth admitted failures to obtain and assess adequate information about First Guardian and to make sufficiently independent enquiries about the risks. It also failed to inform members of potential illiquidity.
On 20 August 2026, the Federal Court declared Netwealth Superannuation Services and Netwealth Investments had contravened the Corporations Act.
As part of a court-enforceable undertaking, Netwealth paid more than $100 million to over 1,000 affected members in January 2026, compensating their net amounts invested in First Guardian.
That is a documented recovery, not a prediction. It is also not evidence that every investor through every platform has received similar compensation.
ASIC did not seek a pecuniary penalty in those proceedings in light of the compensation and circumstances.
ASIC's account of the judgment identifies the admitted and declared failures.
Diversa: allegations about diligence and limits
ASIC has brought proceedings against Diversa Trustees Limited concerning First Guardian. The regulator says around $300 million was invested through superannuation funds for which Diversa was trustee between July 2020 and July 2024.
ASIC alleges inadequate due diligence, weak ongoing monitoring and failure to enforce a 50% holding limit that Diversa had imposed for First Guardian.
A concentration limit is a way to restrict how much of a member's money can be invested in a single option. If a limit is not monitored or enforced, a member could end up with greater exposure to that one investment than the intended safeguard permitted.
These claims are allegations, not a court finding of liability. ASIC is seeking compensation and other orders.
Read the regulator's statement of claim summary.
Equity Trustees: the onboarding question
ASIC also sued Equity Trustees Superannuation Limited, alleging failures in the decision to make First Guardian available to members of NQ Super & Pension.
The regulator says more than $65 million was invested by around 2,700 members between June 2023 and March 2024. ASIC alleges the trustee failed to obtain critical documents such as the fund constitution, audited financial accounts and compliance-plan audit before onboarding First Guardian.
ASIC further alleges that some members were permitted to invest 100% of their funds in First Guardian despite signs it was or might be illiquid.
Again, the lawsuit is not a final verdict. ASIC is asking the court to determine whether the alleged conduct breached legal obligations and whether compensation should be ordered.
ASIC's Equity Trustees proceedings document these specific allegations.
And what about the auditors?
Even where investments are complex, financial statements and compliance audits are supposed to provide an independent check.
In July 2026, ASIC commenced Federal Court proceedings against Auditeo Australia and two auditors, alleging serious deficiencies in the First Guardian financial and compliance-plan audits.
ASIC alleges that approximately $137 million in reported assets were untested in the 2022 financial year and approximately $170 million were untested in 2023. It also alleges audit records do not demonstrate that a 2021 financial audit was conducted despite an audit report being issued.
The accusations are severe, but they remain unproven allegations in ongoing proceedings. The regulator is seeking civil orders against the defendants.
ASIC explains its audit case here.

The presence of proceedings involving multiple participants does not establish that all defendants are liable. Each case must be assessed on its own evidence and legal findings.
An adviser can influence a decision — but whose responsibility follows?
Investors may have been introduced to First Guardian through a financial adviser, sometimes after marketing or lead generation activity. A recommendation to transfer retirement savings carries serious consequences, especially where a large proportion of savings goes into an illiquid or concentrated investment.
ASIC's First Guardian case record describes enforcement action involving advisers and marketing practices, alongside the trustee and fund-manager proceedings.
An investor should not have to work out a regulator's entire investigation before making a complaint. But they do need to identify which organisation advised them, which super fund held their money, which products were recommended and how the switch happened.
Those details may determine which complaint avenues are available and who could be responsible for a particular loss.
What the affair has exposed
One lesson from the case is that the number of professional names surrounding a financial product does not tell an investor how effectively the product was checked.
The existence of audited accounts does not guarantee every important asset was independently tested. The existence of a platform does not mean every option was carefully assessed. And a financial adviser does not make a risky investment safe merely by recommending it.
ASIC has secured a significant compensatory outcome from one platform and is trying to establish liability in other cases. Both facts matter equally.
For Australians still waiting, the next question is immediate: what concrete steps are available to seek their money back?
Next: Can Australians Get Their First Guardian Superannuation Back?.
Primary sources
About this article
This article provides analysis and interpretation of available information. Sources and supporting material, where applicable, are linked within the article.
Found an error? Contact the editorial desk. See our editorial standards and corrections policy.
From the Harbour Creative Blogs archive
Keep exploring this story
Related reporting, people and places from our published coverage. These are editorial connections, not a popularity ranking.
Subject
Superannuation
Australian retirement savings, investment risks and the protections available to investors.
Company
First Guardian
The Australian investment fund at the centre of scrutiny of superannuation losses, regulation and investor protection.
Organisation
Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Australia's corporate and financial services regulator, covering enforcement, consumers and investor protection.

