Part 2 · Analysis
Where Did Australians' Retirement Savings Really Go?
ASIC alleges millions moved through underlying funds into restaurants, property projects and offshore ventures. Following those transactions reveals why oversight is central to this case.
Harbour Creative Team6 min read
Harbour Creative Team6 min read
The $600 Million Superannuation Scandal — Part 2
Reporting reviewed through 12 November 2026. Figures are Australian dollars. Allegations, established court findings and estimated losses are identified separately.
When an Australian moves part of their retirement savings into an investment fund, the account may show a single line: the name of the fund and a value.
Behind that line can sit a much more complicated network of investments, contracts and companies. In First Guardian's case, ASIC alleges that the network helped move substantial sums into ventures with inadequate documentation, security and oversight.
The regulator's central allegation is that around $270 million went through unregistered underlying funds controlled by Falcon Capital. That money was part of the wider First Guardian investment pool, not an additional $270 million on top of the headline amount invested by Australians.
The question is not whether restaurants, breweries, technology companies or property developments are automatically improper investments. They are not. The question is whether the fund's managers properly assessed risks, disclosed conflicts, obtained enforceable documentation and acted in investors' interests.
How did the money travel?
ASIC describes a registered managed investment scheme at the top of the structure, operated by Falcon Capital. Below it were unregistered underlying funds, which then invested in private credit, property and private equity.
The simplified route was:
Australian investors and superannuation savings → First Guardian → underlying investment funds → borrowers and operating businesses.
This is a conceptual outline based on ASIC's description, not an audited tracing of each person's individual dollars. Investors' units in a pooled fund do not let them identify which particular dollar funded a particular company.
The legal identity and valuation of the underlying investments matter for recovery. Liquidators must determine which assets exist, which contracts are enforceable and whether any money can be returned to the fund.
ASIC's 30 October 2026 announcement is the primary account of the allegations set out below.
Restaurants and a brewery
ASIC alleges First Guardian invested in Rogue Traders Group restaurants without adequate due diligence or security. It also identifies an investment in Fox Friday Brewing, despite representations that First Guardian would not invest in businesses operating in alcoholic beverages.
That last point is especially important. Fund documents are supposed to help an investor understand what an investment will and will not do. Where actual investments depart from those descriptions, the inconsistency may undermine informed consent.
The existence of an investment in a business is not proof that the recipient business committed misconduct. ASIC's allegations concern the management and oversight of First Guardian and named defendants.
Offshore transactions under examination
The regulator says at least $15 million was paid to Maleo Indonesia between July 2020 and July 2022 on what it alleges was an undocumented and unsecured basis.
ASIC also alleges Falcon Capital entered agreements with Maleo Singapore that purported to put assets worth $188 million on First Guardian's balance sheets although those assets had no or little value.
It is essential not to misread that $188 million figure as cash necessarily transferred to Maleo Singapore or as a separately proven $188 million loss. ASIC is describing the purported value of assets created by particular agreements. The court has yet to determine its allegations.
These transactions raise two distinct issues: where money actually went, and whether reported assets were valued on a reliable basis. Those are related, but they are not the same accounting question.

Any investment document or financial image should be read alongside the court filings and liquidators' reports; a presentation of value is not itself proof of recoverability.
The property development payments
ASIC alleges Falcon Capital paid at least $27.9 million towards property developments without adequate documentation, security or due diligence.
The amount matters because a development loan normally depends heavily on enforceable repayment terms and security against land or other assets. An investment labelled as secured is not necessarily protected unless the legal documentation, asset position and priorities support that description.
A property project could ultimately succeed, fail or generate a partial recovery. ASIC's statement does not by itself determine the current market value or final outcome of every underlying project.
Payments to connected entities
One of ASIC's most serious sets of allegations concerns at least $57 million paid to entities controlled by Anderson or Selimaj.
A conflict of interest arises when someone responsible for investing other people's money may also have a personal financial interest in a transaction. Such a transaction is not automatically unlawful, but it calls for proper governance, disclosure, independent evaluation and evidence that the decision served investors.
ASIC alleges Anderson controlled investment decisions without meaningful oversight and failed to disclose conflicts; it alleges Selimaj did not adequately monitor Falcon Capital's activities and failed to act in members' best interests.
These matters are contested court allegations. We should not turn them into claims that the money was stolen or that the recipients have been found liable.
Why adding up the figures would be misleading
The figures in ASIC's announcement refer to different types of transactions: amounts paid, assets purportedly recognised, investments into underlying funds and transfers involving related parties. Some may overlap.
Adding $270 million, $188 million, $57 million and other figures into one total would produce an unreliable number. It could count the same underlying investment more than once or mix accounting values with cash movements.
Likewise, ASIC's allegation that an asset had little or no value is a claim to be tested in proceedings; the ultimate recovery position is a question for the liquidators and courts.
This is not a reason to diminish the gravity of the case. It is how readers can distinguish a serious financial investigation from a dramatic but careless headline.
Where the paper trail leads next
A full reconstruction would require bank records, contractual documentation, company accounts, beneficial ownership information and evidence about the use of investor money. The regulator has brought proceedings, and the liquidators are tasked with identifying and recovering available assets.
Those processes may uncover further information, or they may clarify why some assets cannot be recovered in full.
From an investor's perspective, the most uncomfortable possibility is not simply that a particular investment performed badly. It is that the safeguards intended to test and monitor a complex investment may have failed before the losses became visible.
That leads to the next part of the series: what trustees, auditors and advisers were supposed to do, and what the public record actually establishes about their conduct.
Next: Who Was Supposed to Protect First Guardian Investors?.
Primary sources
About this article
This article provides analysis and interpretation of available information. Sources and supporting material, where applicable, are linked within the article.
Found an error? Contact the editorial desk. See our editorial standards and corrections policy.
From the Harbour Creative Blogs archive
Keep exploring this story
Related reporting, people and places from our published coverage. These are editorial connections, not a popularity ranking.
Subject
Superannuation
Australian retirement savings, investment risks and the protections available to investors.
Company
First Guardian
The Australian investment fund at the centre of scrutiny of superannuation losses, regulation and investor protection.
Organisation
Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Australia's corporate and financial services regulator, covering enforcement, consumers and investor protection.

